| 2001 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Longwood | David Wood | Pitcher |
| 1972 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Northport | Neal O'Hara | |
| 1983 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Northport | Rich Vichroski | |
| 1974 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Patchogue | Al Willet | |
| 1986 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Patchogue-Medford | John Thoden | |
| 2008 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Patchogue-Medford | Marcus Stroman | |
| 2009 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Patchogue-Medford | Marcus Stroman | Pitcher |
| 1978 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Sachem | Neal Heaton | |
| 2011 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Sachem North | Alec Sole | |
| 1987 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Keith Osik | |
| 1997 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Chip Pidgeon | Pitcher |
| 2012 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Mike O'Reilly | |
| 2016 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Brian Morell | Pitcher |
| 2017 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Brian Morrell | Shortstop/Pitcher |
| 1988 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Smithtown East | Jim Mecir | |
| 1992 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Smithtown East | Mike Ciminello | |
| 1989 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Smithtown West | Brady Forseth | |
| 2016 | BASEBALL | Silver Slugger Award | Smithtown West | Nick Grande | Shortstop |
| 2007 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Ward Melville | A.J. Nunziato | |
| 2009 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Ward Melville | Steven Matz | |
| 2012 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Ward Melville | Anthony Kay | Pitcher |
| 1993 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | West Babylon | Bill Koch | |
| 1982 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | West Islip | Chris Bayer | |
| 1975 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Whitman | Mike Heiser | |
| 1977 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Whitman | Jim Walker | |
| 2005 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Center Moriches | Glenn Gibson | Pitcher |
| 2006 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Center Moriches | Glenn Gibson | |
| 1969 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Central Islip | Richard Walsh | |
| 2003 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Central Islip | Estee Harris | |
| 1998 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Commack | Rick Riccobono | |
| 2006 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Commack | Mike Belfiore | Pitcher |
| 2008 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Commack | Ryan Pfaeffle | Pitcher |
| 2017 | BASEBALL | Silver Slugger Award | Commack | Peter Theodorellis | Centerfielder/Pitcher |
| 1970 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Commack South | Don DeMola | |
| 1973 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Commack South | Len Locascio | |
| 1981 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Comsewogue | Raf Cepeda | |
| 1998 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Connetquot | B.J. LaMura | Pitcher |
| 1999 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Connetquot | Dominick Ambrosini | |
| 2002 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Connetquot | Scott King | |
| 2004 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Copiague | Dave Collado | Pitcher |
| 2005 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Copiague | David Collado | |
| 1980 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Deer Park | Kevin Baugh | |
| 2000 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Deer Park | Tim Layden | Pitcher |
| 2001 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Deer Park | Tim Layden | |
| 1994 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Hampton | Ross Gload | |
| 1979 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Boomer Esiason | |
| 1984 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Ron Witmeyer | |
| 1985 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Ron Witmeyer | |
| 1990 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Anthony Graffanino | |
| 1995 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Mike Cabales | |
| 1999 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | East Islip | Jason Gouge | Pitcher |
| 2000 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Jason Gouge | |
| 2002 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | East Islip | Brian Johnson | Pitcher |
| 2003 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | East Islip | Brian Johnson | Pitcher |
| 2004 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | East Islip | Brian Johnson | |
| 2007 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Half Hollow Hills East | John Mincone | Pitcher |
| 2017 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Half Hollow Hills East | Patch Dooley | Pitcher |
| 1997 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Half Hollow Hills West | Rob Rizzo | |
| 2011 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Half Hollow Hills West | Remy Jenco | Pitcher |
| 1968 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Huntington | Skip Borowicz | |
| 1971 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Islip | Tom Veryzer | |
| 1976 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Islip | Victor Nicotra | |
| 2010 | BASEBALL | Gibson Award | Islip | Ed Macaluso | Pitcher |
| 1996 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Lindenhurst | Mark Frole | |
| 2010 | BASEBALL | Yastrzemski Award | Lindenhurst | Jimmy Brigga | |
| 2001 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Amityville | Tristan Smith | Guard |
| 2002 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Amityville | Jason Fraser | Center |
| 2003 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Amityville | A.J. Price | Guard |
| 2004 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Amityville | A.J. Price | Guard |
| 1992 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Bay Shore | Gary Williams | Center |
| 1993 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Bay Shore | Gary Williams | Center |
| 1995 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Bay Shore | Kareem Farmer | |
| 1996 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Bay Shore | Brian Ehlers | |
| 2005 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Brentwood | John Garcia | |
| 2015 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Brentwood | Michael Almonacy | Guard |
| 1997 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Bridgehampton | Maurice Manning | |
| 2007 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Copiague | Richard Byrd | |
| 2014 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Deer Park | Aaren Edmead | Guard |
| 2008 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | East Hampton | Mike Russell | |
| 2009 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Greenport | Ryan Creighton | |
| 2010 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Half Hollow Hills West | Tobias Harris | Forward |
| 2011 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Half Hollow Hills West | Tavon Sledge | Guard |
| 2012 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Harborfields | Lucas Woodhouse | Guard |
| 2000 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Longwood | Will McClurkin | |
| 1999 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | North Babylon | Barry Baker | |
| 2013 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Northport | Luke Petrasek | Center |
| 1998 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Westhampton | Dale Menendez | |
| 2006 | BOYS BASKETBALL | Sandler Award | Wyandanch | Chris Barber | |
| 1972 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | BRENTWOOD | Frank Urso | Middie |
| 1979 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | BRENTWOOD | Robert MacAneney | Attackman |
| 1974 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | CENTRAL ISLIP | Bill Carpluk | Middie |
| 1981 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COMSEWOGUE | James M Smith | Middie |
| 1990 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COMSEWOGUE | Joe Romeo | Goalie |
| 1998 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COMSEWOGUE | Nick Russo | Attackman - Middie |
| 1999 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COMSEWOGUE | Kevin Cassese | Middie & Face-Off Specialist |
| 1978 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COPIAGUE | Albert Ray | Middie |
| 2008 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | COPIAGUE | Dwayne Stewart | Attackman |
| 1971 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | DEER PARK | Richard Meister | Defense |
| 1977 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HALF HOLLOW HILLS | James Metzger | Attackman - Middie |
| 1980 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HALF HOLLOW HILLS | Glen Mohrman | Middie |
| 1984 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HALF HOLLOW HILLS | Chris Garvey | Middie |
| 1987 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HALF HOLLOW HILLS | Steven Randby | Goalie |
| 1976 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HARBORFIELDS | Peter Predun | Middie |
| 2012 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HAUPPAUGE | Sam Llinares | Attackman - Middie |
| 1973 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | HUNTINGTON | Bob McGuire | Attackman |
| 2014 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | ISLIP | Kieran Mullins | Attack/Midfield |
| 2003 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | MIDDLE COUNTRY | Larry Cerasi | Attackman |
| 2006 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | MT SINAI | Chris Ritchie | Attackman |
| 1991 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | NORTHPORT | Chris Theofield | Attackman - Middie |
| 1985 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | ROCKY POINT | Scott Reh | Middie |
| 2004 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | ROCKY POINT | Jeff Strittmatter | Attackman - Middie |
| 1996 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SACHEM | Will Campbell | Attackman - Middie |
| 1997 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SACHEM | Justin O'Connell | Defenseman |
| 2005 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | Sachem East | Pat Perritt | Attackman |
| 2000 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SHOREHAM WR | Pete Vlahakis | Middie |
| 2013 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SHOREHAM WR | Tim Rotanz | Attackman |
| 2017 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SHOREHAM WR | Chris Gray | Attack |
| 1982 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SMITHTOWN EAST | Tom Gunderson | Middie |
| 2015 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SMITHTOWN EAST | John Daniggelis | Attack/Midfield |
| 2016 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SMITHTOWN EAST | Gerard Arceri | Faceoff specialist/midfielder |
| 1992 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | SMITHTOWN WEST | Mike LaRocco | Goalie |
| 1994 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WALT WHITMAN | Al Hernandez | Defense |
| 1970 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Mike McCormick | Attackman |
| 1975 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Bill Brown | Attackman |
| 1983 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Chris Walker | Defense |
| 1988 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Joe Matassa | Middie |
| 1989 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | John Banks | Goalie |
| 1993 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Greg Cattrano | Goalie |
| 1995 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Jay Negus | Attackman - Middie |
| 2001 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WARD MELVILLE | Nick Miaritis | Attackman - Middie |
| 1986 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WEST BABYLON | Jonathan Reese | Middie |
| 2007 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WEST ISLIP | Justin Turri | Attackman |
| 2010 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WEST ISLIP | Nicky Galasso | Unspecified Position |
| 2009 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WESTHAMPTON | Kevin Sabo | Attackman - Middie |
| 2002 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WILLIAM FLOYD | Matt Miller | Middie |
| 2011 | BOYS LACROSSE | Ray Enners Award | WILLIAM FLOYD | Luke Miller | Middie |
| 2013 | FIELD HOCKEY | Nancy Cole Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Maggie Revera | Unspecified |
| 2014 | FIELD HOCKEY | Nancy Cole Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Kaitlyn Shanahan | Unspecified |
| 2014 | FIELD HOCKEY | Nancy Cole Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Katie Koester | Unspecified |
| 2014 | FIELD HOCKEY | Roz Mularz Memorial Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Patti Stein | Unspecified |
| 2015 | FIELD HOCKEY | Roz Mularz Memorial Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Mary Lou Assante | Unspecified |
| 2015 | FIELD HOCKEY | Nancy Cole Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Gabrielle Campo | Unspecified |
| 2016 | FIELD HOCKEY | Nancy Cole Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Kassidy Rogers-Healion | Unspecified |
| 2016 | FIELD HOCKEY | Roz Mularz Memorial Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Debbie Brown | Unspecified |
| 2017 | FIELD HOCKEY | Roz Mularz Memorial Award | Unspecified (OOS) | Tina Moon | Unspecified |
| 2017 | FIELD HOCKEY | Suffolk County Player Of The Year | WARD MELVILLE | Keri Thornton | Unspecified |
| 950 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1954 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1955 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1956 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1957 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1960 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1961 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1969 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Amityville | Dan Scott | Tackle |
| 1998 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Amityville | Jesse O'Neill | Lineman |
| 2000 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Amityville | Eugene Nottingham | Running back |
| 2000 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Amityville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Amityville | Darrel Young | Linebacker |
| 2001 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Babylon | Drew Peters | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Babylon | Trevon Rodney | Running back |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Babylon | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Babylon | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Babylon | Jake Carlock | Defensive Back |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Babylon | Jake Carlock | Running Back/Defensive Back |
| 1944 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Cup | Bay Shore | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1951 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Bay Shore | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1969 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Bay Shore | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1983 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Bay Shore | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1984 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Bay Shore | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1984 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Bay Shore | Willy Huff | Lineman |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Bay Shore | Zenel Hudson | Defensive Back |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Bay Shore | Griffin Rock | Center/Linebacker |
| 1980 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Bellport | Rodney Cooke | Running back |
| 1982 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Bellport | Tom Watson | Tackle/Defensive End |
| 1987 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Bellport | Frank Mallia | Lineman |
| 1990 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Bellport | Antonio O'Ferral | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 2001 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Bellport | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2005 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Bellport | Will Strano | Lineman |
| 2005 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Bellport | Stephen Schwicke | Linebacker |
| 2006 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Bellport | Ed Gowins | Running back |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Bellport | Andrew Trent | Wide Receiver |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Tom Cutinella Award | Bellport | Cole Cipp | OTHER |
| 1970 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Brentwood | Jamie Franklin | Running back |
| 1970 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Brentwood | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1971 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Brentwood | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1971 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Brentwood | Curtis Smith | Running back |
| 1999 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Brentwood | Edy Lobo | Linebacker |
| 1999 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Brentwood | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Center Moriches | Jack Donohue | OTHER |
| 1989 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Centereach | Bill Sparacio | Running back |
| 1964 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Central Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1967 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Central Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1976 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Central Islip | Mike Tice | Quarterback |
| 1984 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Central Islip | Randy Beverly | Quarterback |
| 1986 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Central Islip | Roy Barker | Lineman |
| 2006 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Central Islip | Andrew Tiller | Lineman |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Central Islip | Tyree Webster | OTHER |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Central Islip | Eric McCoy | Lineman |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Central Islip | Livingstone Harriott | Quarterback/Safety |
| 1965 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Commack | Gary Steele | Running back |
| 1965 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Commack | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1966 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Commack | Kevin O'Connor | Running back |
| 2000 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Commack | Clint Riggs | Linebacker |
| 1988 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Comsewogue | Adam Mariano | Running back |
| 1990 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Comsewogue | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1994 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Comsewogue | Todd Cassese | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1995 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Comsewogue | Matt DelRosso | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1998 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Comsewogue | Kevin Cassese | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1987 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Connetquot | Rob Grable | Running back |
| 1989 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Connetquot | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1994 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Connetquot | John O'Connell | Linebacker |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Connetquot | Jeremy Leggiero | Linebacker |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Connetquot | Mike Pellegrino | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Connetquot | Mike Pellegrino | Running back |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Connetquot | James Higgins | Wide Receiver |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Connetquot | Sean McKean | Defensive Back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Connetquot | George Wichelns | Defensive Back |
| 1976 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Copiague | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1981 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Copiague | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1979 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Deer Park | Kevin Baugh | Running back |
| 1994 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Deer Park | Adam Brown | Lineman |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Deer Park | Mike Gimeli | Fullback/Linebacker |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Deer Park | Jasawn Thompson | Linebacker |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Deer Park | Jasawn Thompson | Linebacker |
| 1966 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1968 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1975 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1978 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1980 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1982 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | East Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1982 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | East Islip | Ted Gregory | Lineman |
| 1998 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | East Islip | Tim Messner | Linebacker |
| 2006 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | East Islip | Rob Calabrese | Quarterback |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | East Islip | Rob Calabrese | Quarterback |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | East Islip | Bobby Heyward | Lineman |
| 1958 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Greenport | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Greenport-Southold | Jared Schenone | Running Back/Defensive End |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Half Hollow Hills East | D.J. Paul | Wide Receiver/Defensive Back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Half Hollow Hills East | Ernesto Mitchell | Linebacker |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Half Hollow Hills West | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Half Hollow Hills West | JeVahn Cruz | Quarterback |
| 1961 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Harborfields | Jim Smith | Running back |
| 1995 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Harborfields | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1996 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Harborfields | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2001 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Harborfields | Josh Johnston | Running back |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Harborfields | Macon Fessenden | OTHER |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Harborfields | Greg Fitzmaurice | OTHER |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Harborfields | Chris Roy | OTHER |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Hauppauge | Christian Gonzales | OTHER |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Hauppauge | Steven Dill | Tight End/Linebacker |
| 1948 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Huntington | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1949 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Huntington | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1952 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Huntington | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1987 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Huntington | Darren Ward | Running back |
| 1989 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Huntington | John Paci | Quarterback |
| 1999 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Huntington | Chris Mooney | Linebacker/Lineman |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Huntington | Jack Sullivan | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Huntington | Ben Kocis | Quarterback |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Huntington | Christian Jamison | Wide Receiver/Defensive Back |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Huntington | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1988 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Islip | Tim Lynch | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1992 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Islip | Jamie Lynch | Quarterback |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Islip | Alex Gaviria | Linebacker |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Islip | Joe Sabbatino | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Islip | Teddy McLoughlin | OTHER |
| 1983 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Kings Park | Craig Biggio | Running back |
| 1991 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Kings Park | Tucker Grace | Lineman |
| 1995 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Kings Park | Adam Grace | Lineman |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Kings Park | Mike O'Leary | OTHER |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Kings Park | Joe Going | OTHER |
| 1962 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Lindenhurst | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1962 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Lindenhurst | Bob Schroeder | Center |
| 1963 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Lindenhurst | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1992 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Lindenhurst | Terry Mueller | Lineman |
| 1994 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Lindenhurst | Joe Parmentier | Fullback/Linebacker |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Lindenhurst | Mike Gervasio | Lineman |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Lindenhurst | Stephen Skon | Quarterback |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Lindenhurst | Stephen Skon | Quarterback |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Lindenhurst | Stephen Skon | Quarterback |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Lindenhurst | Jeremy Ruckert | Tight End |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Lindenhurst | Jeremy Ruckert | All-purpose |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Lindenhurst | Jeremy Ruckert | Tight End |
| 1993 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Longwood | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1995 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Longwood | Chris Meyer | Linebacker |
| 1996 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Longwood | Marc Riley | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1998 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Longwood | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Longwood | Chris Jean Pierre | Wide Receiver |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Longwood | Darius Greene | Lineman |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Longwood | Matt Weiss | Lineman |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Longwood | Isaiah White | Running back |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Longwood | Isaiah White | Running Back/Defensive Back |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Longwood | Matt Weiss | Lineman |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Longwood | Khalil Owens | Running back |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Miller Place | Andrew Lipski | Linebacker |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Newfield | Ron Denig | Linebacker |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Newfield | Dylan Ferrari | Defensive End |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Newfield | Jelani Greene | Wide Receiver |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Newfield | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Tom Cutinella Award | Newfield | Steven Hoynacky | Tight End/Defensive End |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Newfield | Elijah Riley | Defensive Back |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Newfield | Elijah Riley | Wide Receiver/Defensive Back |
| 1973 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | North Babylon | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1996 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | North Babylon | Henson Harrison | Lineman |
| 1997 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | North Babylon | Justin Stark | Lineman |
| 1997 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | North Babylon | Justin Stark | Lineman |
| 1998 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | North Babylon | Barry Baker | Running Back/Safety |
| 1999 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | North Babylon | Omar Palmer | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | North Babylon | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | North Babylon | Jason Gwaltney | Running back |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | North Babylon | Jason Gwaltney | Running back |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | North Babylon | Preshod McCoy | Running back |
| 1967 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Northport | Frank Ahrenhold | Tackle |
| 1991 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Northport | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1991 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Northport | David Sumner | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 1993 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Northport | Mark Dantuono | Lineman |
| 1996 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Northport | Chris Burnham | Running Back/Defensive Back |
| 2010 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Northport | Jack Delahunty | Wide Receiver |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Northport | Dan Preston | Running Back/Safety |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | Northport | Frankie Stola | Defensive Back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Esiason Award | Northport | Ryan Walsh | Quarterback |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Northport | Sam Gozelski | Lineman |
| 1991 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Patchogue - Medford | Mike Hansen | Lineman |
| 1988 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Patchogue-Medford | Mark Zumpol | Lineman |
| 1996 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Patchogue-Medford | Derrick Rossy | Linebacker |
| 1997 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Patchogue-Medford | Derrick Rossy | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 1997 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Patchogue-Medford | Derrick Rossy | Linebacker |
| 1997 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Patchogue-Medford | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2001 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Patchogue-Medford | Matt Speis | Lineman |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Patchogue-Medford | Chris Pugliese | Lineman |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Patchogue-Medford | Jordany Diejuste | Lineman |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Patchogue-Medford | Sean Christie | Lineman |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | Patchogue-Medford | Connor Coughlin | Wide Receiver |
| 1959 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Port Jefferson | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1963 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Port Jefferson | Hal Becker | Running back |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Port Jefferson | Brian Mark | OTHER |
| 1953 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Riverhead | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1981 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Riverhead | Scott Hackal | Lineman |
| 1988 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Riverhead | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Riverhead | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Riverhead | Mike Heigh | Lineman |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Riverhead | Ed Wansor | Quarterback |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Riverhead | Miguel Maysonet | Running back |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Riverhead | Miguel Maysonet | Running back |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Riverhead | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Riverhead | Malcolm Cater | Linebacker |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Riverhead | Malcolm Cater | Linebacker |
| 1977 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sachem | Brian Dehler | Quarterback |
| 1977 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Sachem | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1983 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sachem | Mike Farley | Lineman |
| 1985 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sachem | Mark Wojciechowski | Lineman |
| 1986 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Sachem | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1990 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sachem | Peter Maiello | Lineman |
| 1992 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sachem | Dennis Kramer | Running Back/Defensive Back |
| 1995 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sachem | James O'Neal | Running back |
| 2005 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sachem | Tim Miller | Lineman |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Sachem East | Dan Carroll | Lineman |
| 2009 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Sachem East | Jerry Allen | OTHER |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Sachem East | Steven Casali | Linebacker |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Sachem East | Steven Casali | Linebacker |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sachem East | Steven Casali | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Sachem East | Steven Casali | Running back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sachem East | Dan Carroll | Lineman |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | Dragon Award | Sachem North | William Slinkosky | Wide Receiver |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sachem North | Cong Tian | Tackle |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sachem North | Dalton Crossan | Running back |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Sachem North | Dalton Crossan | Running back |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sachem North | Steven Mills | Lineman |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Sachem North | Michael Slattery | Defensive Lineman |
| 2013 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Sachem North | Malik Pierre | Running Back/Defensive Back |
| 1972 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sayville | Chad Smith | Quarterback |
| 1972 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Sayville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1986 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sayville | Brian Kolar | Lineman |
| 1989 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sayville | Tom Dolan | Lineman |
| 1990 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sayville | Jason Mastropierro | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 2000 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Sayville | Peter Martocci | Lineman |
| 2001 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Sayville | Eric Nieugebauer | Linebacker |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Sayville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Sayville | Billy O'Connor | Linebacker |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Dragon Award | Sayville | Nick Stover | Wide Receiver |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Sayville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Sayville | Steven Ferreira | Quarterback |
| 2012 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Sayville | James Giattino | Wide Receiver/Safety |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Sayville | Jack Coan | Quarterback |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | Sayville | Jack Coan | Quarterback |
| 2015 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Sayville | Liam Bailey | Linebacker |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Esiason Award | Sayville | Jack Coan | Quarterback |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Sayville | Jack Coan | Quarterback |
| 2007 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Trevor Johnson | OTHER |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Tom Cutinella Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Aaron Harley-Rey | Linebacker |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | 12th Man Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2014 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Shoreham-Wading River | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Shoreham-Wading River | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Tom Cutinella Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Kevin Cutinella | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Ethan Wiederkehr | Lineman |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | Shoreham-Wading River | Ethan Wiederkehr | Lineman |
| 1964 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Smithtown | Bob Lavinia | Running back |
| 1985 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Smithtown | Eric Trenaman | Quarterback |
| 1947 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Southampton | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1968 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Southampton | Tom Tarazevits | Tackle |
| 1993 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Southampton | Chris Ott | OTHER |
| 1975 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Ward Melville | Chris Dieterich | Tackle |
| 1987 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Ward Melville | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1960 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | West Babylon | Len Sears | Tackle |
| 1999 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | West Babylon | Mike McGrorty | Lineman |
| 2004 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | West Babylon | Kevin Hennessy | Quarterback |
| 2005 | FOOTBALL | Boomer Award | West Babylon | Eric Romanchuk | Quarterback |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | NFF Receiver Award | West Babylon | Michael Richardson | Wide Receiver |
| 2011 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | West Babylon | Michael Richardson | Defensive Back |
| 1978 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | West Islip | Kevin Riccio | Linebacker/Lineman |
| 1985 | FOOTBALL | Zellner Award | West Islip | Mike Hayes | Lineman |
| 1985 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | West Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 1992 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | West Islip | Dom Pellegrino | Linebacker |
| 1994 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | West Islip | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | West Islip | Lou Morga | Tight End/Defensive End |
| 2003 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | West Islip | Troy Turri | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 2006 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | West Islip | Justin Turri | Quarterback/Defensive Back |
| 2008 | FOOTBALL | Cassese Award | West Islip | Kyle Gelling | Defensive Back |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Burnett Award | West Islip | Tim Mullane | Lineman |
| 2002 | FOOTBALL | Collotta Award | Westhampton | Matt Montpetit | Linebacker |
| 2016 | FOOTBALL | Joe Cipp Jr. Award | Westhampton | Dylan Laube | Running back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Hansen Award | Westhampton | Dylan Laube | Running back |
| 2017 | FOOTBALL | Cipp Award | Westhampton | Dylan Laube | Running back |
| 1974 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Whitman | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2000 | FOOTBALL | LaBue Award | Whitman | Nick Woll | Running Back/Linebacker |
| 1987 | FOOTBALL | Rutgers Trophy | Wyandanch | Unspecified | OTHER |
| 2001 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Bellport | Molly Brothers | Center |
| 2015 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Bellport | Arella Guirantes | Guard |
| 2011 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Center Moriches | Amber Davis | |
| 1996 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Commack | Danielle Hurley | |
| 2007 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Commack | Samantha Prahalis | Guard |
| 2008 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Commack | Samantha Prahalis | Guard |
| 2002 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Copiague | Kia Wright | Guard |
| 2003 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Copiague | Angie Clark | Forward |
| 2009 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Copiague | Ieasia Walker | |
| 2000 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Miller Place | Michelle Stevens | |
| 2010 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | North Babylon | Bria Hartley | Guard |
| 1992 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Northport | Cami Ruck | |
| 1994 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Northport | Kim Ruck | |
| 2004 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Northport | Kaylie Schiavetta | Guard |
| 1995 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Sachem | Nicole Kaczmarski | Guard |
| 1997 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Sachem | Nicole Kaczmarski | Guard |
| 1998 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Sachem | Nicole Kaczmarski | Guard |
| 1999 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Sachem | Nicole Kaczmarski | Guard |
| 2014 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Sachem East | Katie Doherty | Guard |
| 1993 | GIRLS BASKETBALL | Clark Award | Wyandanch | Jamie Ward | |
|
